On the open letter, and accept the Morning Post interview, Li Tuo's response to controversy in the academic community. Scholar He Weifang, Ben Xu received, respectively, Post reporters respond to and refute the views of Li Tuo.
Post reporter Dan Jianfeng
ago, in an open letter and the Post interview, Li Tuo biased media reports had expressed some dissatisfaction, and further that,UGGs, of academic factionalism. Wang Binbin
published article, is within the nature of academic criticism, the media is providing a platform. Although I'd tried to find some famous scholars defended the teacher for the Wang, but did not receive a positive response, we published three articles were testify Wang Hui teacher suspected of plagiarism, which is due to objective reasons, not the subjective intent. One netizen put it well: each of the arguments now, together, I'm afraid there are three or four hundred thousand words, and this is clearly not arranged in any media can. We have to participate, it is also the subject Juyou Public performance. So the whole, this is a normal process of interaction between various opinions. Post interview that, even if tendentious media reports, is not a problem, is always one-sided, it should be one-sided, because it has real attraction, like the apple falling from a tree, must be to the ground, not to other Fang Xiangfei. the real reason people of all lead in one direction, The fact is that one-sided. this fact is no different opinion. There are two different views. First, the fact that we can do different 'name', name a view. For instance, some people say that this is 'plagiarism', while others others say it is 'academic non-standard', say 'plagiarism' or is 'academic non-standard' is the 'Wang Hui misappropriation of the views of others' view of the fact. view on the treatment of Wang Hui, misappropriation or misappropriation of others, is very severe. and still others to do the past is past, do not pursue the matter, you can let the matter rest. These are the views,UGG boots clearanc, different views are required to prove reasonable. That is reason. However, Ben Xu that, no matter how proven view is not a substitute for the truth, no matter what kind of view, should speak out himself. constitutes plagiarism. discuss such issues do not need long-winded, is fully able to bear the mass media. Li Tuo the paradox lies in one hand, he accused the Department of newspapers just south of articles critical of Wang Hui, on the other hand their support for the Wang Hui men are but do not write. The truth is that all those who even Wang Ting Wang Hui Wang Binbin I and others can not for the black and white copy of the list to make even a little convincing evidence to the defense. In addition, Li Tuo also tried to discuss the political pull to this intention it is called 'ulterior motives'. plagiarism According to the survey report the decision to comply with the above principle: According to the exact identification of the evidence without pay, suspension or removal decision. so dedicated research program, will the parties deserve punishment, so access to China's restructuring of academic order opportunities for errors to correct style of study are thus available. China can move toward a virtuous cycle academic end for. If President of Tsinghua University, unwilling to make the appointment of Dean of Arts 'Wang Hui, the Commission alleged plagiarism' decision,UGG boots cheap, obviously enough, they did not to take responsibility for their own should step down. judgments. Li Tuo also believe that the media and the Internet to participate in this event has its limitations, he also believes that, with the involvement of Yu-sheng, This surface. But many academics expressed opposition to the views of Li Tuo.
overseas scholars to write letter of support signed Wang Hui
◎ news
Recently, a Solidarity sponsored by overseas scholars, and Wang Hui's letter presented to the signature of President of Tsinghua University the letter began circulating on the Internet, in a letter to Wang Hui these scholars of
inscribed to this solidarity with the last letter was signed Solidarity with the letter also mentioned several events in support of the overseas scholars and Wang Hui, founder of Solidarity, who is Columbia University Professor Liu He, University of Bologna, Italy, Department of Oriental Languages Baoxia Lan (Claudia Pozzana), Professor, New York University ( Rebecca Karl) and so on. But scholars are not yet know how many signed the letter in support.
solidarity letter first of all that, Nanjing University Professor Wang Binbin written comments on the article on Wang Hui's negligence in the article, the same paper as the snowball snowballing, and Yu Ying-shih Yu-sheng Chinese American scholars accused of Wang Hui - about his immoral and violations of international academic norms - now has caused a media frenzy of. and little is known about academic standards. belong. Gu Binglin to this and presented to President of Tsinghua University Vice President Xie and signed letter also has appeared on the network, the letter said,UGG shoes, and commented in a friendly way, translated the works of Professor Wang Hui. Wang Hui, the nearest work. Each translator has checked and checked again Professor Wang in the past three decades a large number of literature published in all the footnotes. no matter how broad understanding of the definition of the word plagiarism, these translators are not find any evidence of plagiarism. common. Many of us have witnessed a lot of media attacks, a common feature of these attacks is the contempt for academic research as well as how to make the daily life of Academic richer do not understand the natural sciences, social sciences, humanities avoided social life and art. Finally,
article from the [left bank of the Cultural Network] belongs to all of the original authors.
loading, please wait ......
No comments:
Post a Comment